Title: Why is Polo drum brake? ——Analysis of the dispute over the brake configuration of Volkswagen Polo
Recently, the brake configuration of Volkswagen Polo has become a hot topic in the automotive industry. Many consumers have found that the new Polo still uses a drum brake design in the rear wheel, which is in sharp contrast to the phenomenon that competitors of the same level are generally equipped with disc brakes. This article will combine the hot data of the entire network for the past 10 days to analyze this dispute from three dimensions: technology, cost and market.
1. Hot data statistics on the whole network
| platform | Related topics | Core dispute points |
|---|---|---|
| 28,000 | Does the drum brake affect safety | |
| Autohome | 12,000 | Cost control vs. distribution reduction dispute |
| Zhihu | 4300+ answers | Technical backwardness vs. Enoughism |
| Tik Tok | 150 million views | Comparison of actual braking distances |
2. Comparison of drum brake and disc brake performance
| Comparison items | Drum brake | Disk brake |
|---|---|---|
| Braking power | Stronger at the beginning | Linear stability |
| Heat dissipation | Poor | excellent |
| Maintenance cost | 30-40% lower | Higher |
| Service life span | 80,000-100,000 kilometers | 60,000-80,000 kilometers |
3. Popular official response points
1. Emphasize that the Polo drum brake system has been specially adjusted, with a braking distance of 100-0km/h of 38.2 meters, reaching the same level of standard
2. It is pointed out that the rear wheel braking force accounts for only 30%, and the drum brake is enough to meet the demand
3. Explain that this design can reduce the user's later maintenance costs
4. Denied allegations of reduction of distribution, saying that global versions are unified
4. Differences in industry experts' opinions
| Supporters' opinions | Opposite view |
|---|---|
| 90% of the working conditions of a household car does not require high-performance brakes | Disk brake has become the mainstream configuration in the market |
| Drum brakes perform more stably on rainy days | The heat attenuation is obvious during continuous braking |
| Reduce the price of the whole vehicle to benefit consumers | There are hidden security risks |
5. Consumer test data
A comparative test organized by a certain automobile media showed:
- Regular braking of urban roads: the difference between the two brake systems is ≤3%
- Continuous downhill of mountain roads: the braking distance of drum brake group increases by 12%
- Braking after wading: drum brake recovery speed is 2-3 seconds slow
6. Comparison of market competitive product configurations
| Car model | Rear wheel braking type | Starting price (10,000 yuan) |
|---|---|---|
| Volkswagen Polo | Drum brake | 9.99 |
| Honda Fit | Disk brake | 10.28 |
| Toyota Zhixuan | Disk brake | 8.58 |
7. Analysis of technological development trends
1. Data from the EU New Car Safety Evaluation Association (Euro NCAP) shows that after 2015, disc brakes have become the mainstream
2. Electric vehicles have reduced dependence on mechanical braking due to kinetic energy recovery system
3. Within Volkswagen Group: Audi A1 and Skoda Jingrui have fully adopted disc brakes
4. Industry forecast: A0-class disc brake penetration rate will reach 85% in 2025
Conclusion:
This controversy reflects the game between consumers' expectations for automotive configuration upgrades and manufacturers' cost control. Although the application of drum brakes on Polo complies with regulatory standards, Volkswagen may need to reevaluate the configuration strategy in the context of consumption upgrades. It is recommended that car buyers choose according to the actual use scenario: economical benefits can be considered for transportation in cities, and disc brake models are recommended to be preferred if they often travel on mountain roads or long distances.
check the details
check the details
en
